Performance, power, and thermal analysis of low-power processors for scale-out systems

Abstract

There is increased interest, in high-performance computing as well as in commercial datacenters, in so-called scale-out systems, where large numbers of low-cost and low-power-dissipation servers are used for workloads which have available coarse-grained parallelism. One target class of devices for building scale-out systems is the class of low-power processors, such as those based on the ARM® architecture, the Power Architecture®, and the Intel® Atom™ processor. This article presents a detailed characterization of three contemporary low-power processors covering all the aforementioned ISAs, all implemented in state-of-the-art 45 nm semiconductor processes. Processor performance, power dissipation, thermal load, and board-level power dissipation apportionment are presented, via a combination of hardware performance counters, OS-level timing measurements, current measurements, and thermal imaging via a microbolometer array. It is demonstrated that while certain processors might provide low power dissipation, the most energy-efficient platform depends on the characteristics of the application, and the design of the entire platform (including integrated versus on-board peripherals, power supply regulators, etc.). The lowest-power platform showed a power-efficiency advantage of almost four times lower idle power dissipation, and almost five times lower active power dissipation for a single-threaded workload, versus the highest-power-dissipation platform studied. The latter however achieved a factor of two better energy-efficiency than its closest competitor, when executing a throughput-oriented workload, due to significantly better compute performance and available hardware concurrency. © 2011 IEEE.